Back to recipes
πŸ₯£
Old Floridaβ€’Sideβ€’Medium
πŸ₯• Vegetarian🌾 Gluten-Free

St. Augustine Grits

Stone-ground cheese grits folded with house pimento cheese and a whisper of St. Augustine datil pepper.

πŸ“ Notes: Also known as: Datil Dust Grits Β· Miz Kathi's Pimento Grits The concept: Classic: Southern cheese grits. Vectors: Substitution (house pimento cheese replaces plain cheddar in the grits base) + Terroir swap (datil pepper replaces generic cayenne for heat). Two already-trained pantry components become one new side with zero new SKUs beyond the pepper itself. Hero ingredient: Datil pepper β€” St. Augustine's own pepper varietal, fruity-hot rather than flat-hot like cayenne. Components: House Pimento Cheese β€” use existing house recipe as-is; do not build a special small batch. Plating: Scoop 4 oz into ramekin or plate quenelle-style. Garnish with extra datil mince or smoked paprika dust and chive. Pro upgrade: finish with a datil-brown-butter drizzle (brown 2 oz butter, bloom 1 tsp datil mince off heat) for an upsell version. Prep efficiency: cook grits base ahead and hold; fold in pimento cheese and datil only at pass in small batches. Cross-utilization: uses two existing pantry items β€” cheese grits base and pimento cheese β€” zero new equipment. Datil pepper also feeds Datil Hoppin' John and Datil Creamed Corn. Failure modes: adding pimento cheese over direct heat breaks the emulsion β€” always fold off heat. Scaling: At 4x: taste and adjust datil up only ~3x, not 4x β€” heat compounds faster than volume. At 10x: cook grits in two pots β€” a single pot this size loses too much heat to steam-jacket evenly.
⏱ Prep 22mπŸ”₯ Cook 34mπŸ•’ Total 56m🍽 10 servings
#premium#old florida#grain#starch
Your rating:
✨

Ask Chef AI

Scan this recipe for pairings, improvements, nutrition β€” or ask anything.

Transform this recipe

Servings
10
Units
Oven temp

Ingredients

  • 5 oz (2 cups)Grits, stone-ground, dry
  • 3/8 qtWhole milk
  • 3/8 qtWater
  • 1 2/3 ozButter
  • 7/8 cups (16 oz)House Pimento Cheese
  • 3/8 TbspDatil pepper, fresh, minced, seeded
  • 1/4 tspWhite pepper

Nutrition / serving

No nutrition data for this recipe β€” tap Nutrition in Ask Chef AI above for an estimate.

Cost estimate

$6.10
Total (10 servings)
$0.61
Per serving

Approximate β€” US national average ($0.52–$0.73/serving range).

My notes

Method

  1. 1

    Combine milk and water in a heavy-bottom pot, bring to a low boil.

  2. 2

    Whisk in grits in a steady stream. Reduce to low simmer.

  3. 3

    Cook 25–30 min, whisking every 3–4 min, until grits pull off the spoon in a ribbon.

  4. 4

    Off heat, fold in butter until melted.

  5. 5

    Fold in pimento cheese until fully incorporated and glossy β€” do not return to high heat, cheese will break.

  6. 6

    Fold in datil mince and white pepper. Salt to taste.

Reviews

Sign in to leave a review.